Movables vs Fixtures: Understanding Property Attachments in Real Estate Sales

07 July 2025 35

In property transactions, a recurring point of confusion arises around whether certain items - like satellite dishes, bathroom mirrors, or bar stools - should remain with the property after a sale or be removed by the seller. The issue often hinges on the legal classification of such items as either movables or fixtures, a distinction that can significantly impact the outcome of a sale.

This article explores the difference between movable and immovable property, with a particular focus on satellite dishes as a case study. Understanding this distinction is essential for both buyers and sellers to avoid disputes and ensure a smooth transfer of property.

In South African property law, assets are generally classified into two categories:

  • Movable property includes items that are not permanently attached to the land or buildings and can be relocated without damage. Common examples are furniture, freestanding appliances, and vehicles.
  • Immovable property refers to land and any permanent structures or fixtures that are affixed to it, such as buildings, built-in cupboards, plumbing installations, and security gates.

When a dispute arises about whether an item is a fixture or a movable, South African courts typically rely on three key factors:

  1. Nature and purpose of the attachment: Was the item intended to be a permanent part of the property?
  2. Degree and manner of attachment: How firmly is it affixed? Can it be removed without damaging the structure?
  3. Intention of the annexor: Did the owner install the item with the intention that it would remain permanently?

Satellite dishes are a common source of ambiguity in property transactions. Although mounted to a wall or roof, they are generally not considered fixtures under South African law for the following reasons:

  • Non-permanence: Satellite dishes are usually installed with the expectation that they can be removed or upgraded as needed.
  • Ease of removal: They can typically be detached without causing structural damage to the property.
  • Service-specific use: Their purpose is functional and service-related, rather than being integral to the structure of the building.

Because of these characteristics, satellite dishes are usually classified as movable property. However, if a seller intends to leave the dish in place - or a buyer expects it to remain - this must be explicitly stated in the sale agreement to prevent disputes.

The classification of various household items often depends on their degree of attachment:

  • Bar stools: If simply placed under a counter, they are movables. Built-in or permanently fixed stools may be considered fixtures.
  • Bathroom mirrors: Freestanding mirrors are movables; however, those that are permanently mounted may be deemed fixtures.
  • Curtains and pelmets: Curtains are generally considered movable, while pelmets, if fixed to the structure, may be fixtures.
  • Curtain blinds: Like pelmets, blinds that are affixed to the window frame may be classified as fixtures.

To avoid costly legal disputes, buyers and sellers should:

  • Clearly list items included in or excluded from the sale.
  • Define the status of ambiguous items like satellite dishes in the deed of sale.
  • Ensure that the intention of both parties regarding fixtures and movables is documented in writing.

A well-drafted sale agreement is the best tool for avoiding misunderstandings, especially when items fall into a legal grey area.

Items such as satellite dishes, bar stools, and bathroom mirrors are generally considered movable property unless they are installed in a manner that suggests permanence. Their classification hinges on the intention of the installer, how firmly they are attached, and how integral they are to the building.

While South African law does not provide an exhaustive list of what constitutes a fixture, courts consistently apply the three-factor test outlined above. Therefore, to avoid uncertainty, it is essential that the sale agreement specifies the status of such items. This clarity can save both parties from future disputes and help ensure a smooth property transfer process.

Related Expertise: Property Transfer
Share: